Comet Lodge Cemetery: Limbo Part II


Part II: From 1938 to present day  

Woodmen of the World memorial

In 1938, Odd Fellow members still owning cemetery land parcels fell behind in property tax payments. The county foreclosed and became, whether through design or accident, the new owner of Comet Lodge Cemetery. For the next fifteen years, questions over what was purchased, restoration permissions, and street widening ordinances, drifted back and forth between the city treasurer, council, and local improvement societies.  

Eventually, official non-action moved the questions to the back burner and the county seemingly forgot that it ever owned a cemetery. Comet Lodge Cemetery became both a home for transients and a byword for ‘eyesore’ for several more decades.  

A circle of headstone bases


Almost 100 years after its official Odd Fellows designation, new attempts to build on cemetery grounds ignited a public fury. Preservation Seattle noted that in 1987, a local resident began clearing the site in what appeared to be a simple restoration effort. That illusion quickly vanished.  

“When he began bulldozing the property, and the graves of the 200 or so individuals buried there, the real plans became vividly clear [and] quirkier than anyone realized. What initially looked like restoration activity was really part of the man’s life-long dream to live on a cemetery. He intended to build his house there.”  

Another report offers more details.  

A group called Elysian Fields claiming ownership of Comet Lodge Cemetery, decided to build a “caretakers cottage” on the site and plant foodstuffs for the local community. By the time the Washington State Cemetery Board brought in an order to cease and desist, the majority of headstones had been bulldozed to the south end of the property.”  

Since that time, twenty restoration attempts for Comet Lodge have been made. All have failed. Even HistoryLink’s 2009 work only managed to relocate twelve headstones while the remaining markers are little more than broken bits and pieces. Out of the hundreds of missing headstones, only six remain in their original plots.  

A serene view


Today, King County and the Washington State Cemetery Association retain custodial responsibility of the site. Only a few aesthetically placed headstones remain to tell passers-by of its original purpose and Comet Lodge now seems more a park than a cemetery. However, for one resident living near the old Baby Land portion, the calm appearance will never deceive. The decades-old scandal, plus certain inexplicable activities within her house, have rendered the property un-saleable.  

Online sources:  

City and County records of Comet Lodge destruction  

These are matters of grave importance. PDF, pp, 4, 16  

No stone unturned: One man’s lonely battle to save the graveyard City Hall would rather forget  

Washington State law concerning abandoned cemeteries Cemetery records for Comet Lodge  


• Seattle Post Intelligencer: “A grave commentary on an old cemetery.” October 16, 1997.  

• Seattle Times: “New life for an old cemetery: Project organizers want to turn it into an horticultural park.” September 25, 1985.  

• Seattle Post-Intelligencer: “Cemetery slated to make a resurrection: Comet Lodge site will be turned into a memorial park.” June 17, 1999.  

3 Responses

  1. Kristy
    Kristy March 1, 2010 at 10:23 am | | Reply

    Pretty spooky. I can understand why neighbors think their land is haunted.

  2. cometlodgecemetery.
    cometlodgecemetery. February 15, 2011 at 11:59 am | | Reply

    Some good links and story about this desecrated spot. Still sad that court actions are needed to restore this dog park to a final resting spot for our earliest settlers and Natives. Both the City and County continue to hold on to the lie that houses lie atop the section of the cemetery reserved for babies. This is a fact that cannot be disputed. Both the City and County continue to deny that the City bulldozed the stones from their original locations above the remains, on All Souls Day, November 2, 19878. The City records are clear that they bulled the stones as they were trenching the grounds putting in a sewer main through the property.

  3. Rani S
    Rani S May 6, 2018 at 7:35 pm | | Reply

    thanks for sharing this information..

Leave a Reply

Connect with Facebook

Follow by Email